The U.S. Supreme Court rendered a decision about the applicability of 28 USC § 1782 (a U.S. statutory mechanism that allows parties in a litigation outside of the U.S. to obtain documents and oral pretrial deposition testimony from persons and entities, regardless of whether they are parties to the foreign proceeding, in the U.S.) to international private commercial arbitration and investor arbitration.
The United States Circuit Courts had been split for several decades on the issue of whether 1782 can be utilized to obtain discovery in connection with an international arbitration. The Courts had been divided on the issue of whether a commercial arbitration tribunal constitutes a “foreign or international tribunal” within the meaning of 1782. The term “tribunal” appears in 1782 without any qualifying language. Specifically, the Courts disagreed on the issue of whether the term “foreign tribunal” is sovereign-centric, and its meaning is limited to tribunals that act under the authority of a government, or whether this term also includes tribunals convened by private parties, including tribunals organized by private parties to an arbitration. Recently, the United States Supreme Court accepted petitions for certiorari to ultimately reach a resolution.
The Supreme Court decided that 1782 is not applicable to international private commercial arbitration and investor arbitration. In a unanimous decision, the Court held that “only a governmental or intergovernmental adjudicative body constitutes a ‘foreign or international tribunal’” under 1782. See ZF Automotive U.S., Inc., et al., v. Luxshare, Ltd., (Docket No. 21-401); AlixPartners, LLC, et al., v. The Fund for Protection of Investor Rights in Foreign States, (Docket No. 21-518). An ad hoc arbitration panel, which is not conferred with governmental authority, does not meet this requirement. This decision will undoubtedly have a large impact on international arbitration. In cases where there is pretrial evidence to be gathered in the U.S., it may make sense for counsel to consider litigation, rather than arbitration, as the dispute resolution mechanism. We are available to answer any questions you may have concerning 1782 proceedings.